FYI: Relax & Chill includes affiliate links, and we may receive a small commission if you buy through them – all at no added cost for you!
Top 9 Pizza Spots for the Best Pizza in Williamsburg, VA
Williamsburg, VA has plenty of great places to grab some grub. From fine dining to historical experiences, the city has something to offer anyone who has worked up an appetite exploring Colonial Williamsburg.
But sometimes, all you really want is a great pizza. Well, no worries there either. Here’s your list of all the best pizza restaurants in Williamsburg, VA.
Italian Restaurants and Pizzerias in Williamsburg
If you’re looking for a spot that has more on the menu than just pizza, then there are plenty of Italian restaurants that serve delicious pizza along with pasta and classic Italian dishes. While many pizza restaurants in the city offer takeout and delivery options, there’s also a touch of ambiance and warmth to the entries on this list that make it worth spending the time dining in.
The following Italian restaurants can certainly satisfy any pasta cravings you might have – but more importantly, they all serve some of the best pizza pies in Williamsburg, VA.
Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano
Address: 801 Merrimac Trail E, Williamsburg, VA 23185
Antonio’s is a family-owned restaurant named after its Sicilian-born chef. This local eatery offers both northern and southern cuisine and an intimate dining experience with friendly staff.
All the sauces are handmade from scratch, and the restaurant offers gluten-free pizza and pasta, including a cauliflower pizza crust. This is one of the best pizza spots in Virginia when it comes to authentic Italian flavors at reasonable prices, no matter whether you’re ordering thin crust, thicker Sicilian pizzas or a square pizza crust.
Antonio’s also offers classic staples, like margarita and Hawaiian pizzas, and specialty pizzas like the caprese with fresh mozzarella, vine-ripe tomatoes, arugula and a white sauce of garlic, olive oil and basil, with a balsamic glaze. Insider tip: the garlic knots are a local favorite and a great way to start your meal.
Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta
Address: 5540 Olde Towne Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Olde Towne offers classic Italian food and New York Style pizza. There are gluten-free pizzas available, their thin crust is baked to crispy perfection and the chicken parmesan is a fan favorite. There’s also thick, square Sicilian pizza crusts available to order. Another star of the menu is Sakir’s pizza, which features chicken cutlets and philly steak with onions and mozzarella cheese.
There are takeout and delivery options available, but Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta offers many dine-in specials to get visitors inside the restaurant (like 50% off any bottle of wine on Wednesdays). The friendly staff and homey atmosphere of the restaurant are great perks, but the main attraction is definitely the Naples-quality pizza.
Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza
Address: 2021-D, Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185
Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza has classic lasagna, penne alla vodka, cheese ravioli, hot subs and sandwiches (we’re talking chicken parmigiana subs topped with marinara and mozzarella and classic Philly cheese steaks).
But, the real star at Anna’s is its namesake brick-oven pizzas. Anna grew up in Sicily and ran Italian restaurants in both Brooklyn, New York and New Jersey… and now she’s brought her Sicilian-style brick oven pizzas to Williamsburg, Virginia! If you love thick, light and crispy pizza crusts, Anna’s is definitely your go-to.
Their BBQ chicken pizza is a favorite of locals. If you’re looking for some seafood with your slice, consider trying their Pizza Mira Mare topped with shrimp, scallops, an olive oil base and mozzarella cheese.
Or, if you’re feeling less risky, you can’t go wrong with a good old-fashioned Scilian pepperoni pizza cooked with some “old-world” style.
Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza offers a warm, family friendly dine-in experience, as well as catering, pick up, and delivery services.
Sal’s By Victor
Address: 1242 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Sal’s has a diverse menu featuring Italian cuisine but also classic American dishes like cheeseburgers and Philly cheese steak subs. Customers also love the deserts at Sal’s, and there’s an extensive wine selection to match the menu, too.
They have delicious gluten-free pizzas, but their white pizza is especially fantastic. A stand-out specialty pizzas is the Campagnole pizza, with garlic and oil sauce, grilled chicken, parmigiano cheese and fresh chopped veggies like spinach, broccoli, and tomatoes. The seafood pizza is also popular among adventurous slice-seekers featuring shrimp and crab meat paired with mozzarella cheese.
Sal’s by Victor offers new and traditional tastes for very reasonable prices. Takeout and delivery options are available, but the warm environment and the live Italian music on Friday nights makes it worth dining in.
The restaurant also has authentic Italian jewelry from sculptor Nino Rose that you can buy as a souvenir. If you’re looking for a truly magical and authentic Italian experience during your trip to Colonial Williamsburg in addition to great pizza, Sal’s is truly the place to go.
Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg
Maybe you’re feeling more of a pizza joint vibe rather than a full-on traditional Italian restaurant experience during your trip to Williamsburg VA. If so, there are many pizzerias where the pie is the most important player on the team – check out some of these top 9 best pizza places.
Two Sisters Pizzeria
Address: 4506 John Tyler Hwy, Williamsburg, VA 23185
One of the most wonderful things about the Two Sisters Pizzeria is that you’re treated like family when you walk through the door. This is a local, family-owned pizza joint and the owner and the friendly staff are famous for doing everything they can to accommodate their guests.
In addition to pizza, there are kabobs, baklava and gyros on the menu that customers adore. When it comes to pizza, Chicken Tikka is the most popular among their specialties. This pie features spinach, ricotta, mozzarella cheese and garlic along with grilled marinated chicken.
Blaze Pizza
Address: 5134 Main St, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Trendy and hip, Blaze Pizza is the best place to go for creative and inventive pizzas. Blaze has over 30 toppings that customers can select from for a true BYO pizza experience, which sets it apart from other chain pizza joints like Papa Johns and Pizza Hut.
Another element that sets Blaze apart is their selection of healthy options. Blaze pizza has three gluten-free pizza options and vegan pizza, as well – making it one of the best dining spots to go if you’ve got diet restrictions. This pizza spot is also perfect for quick counter-service and oven-fired pizza without sacrificing quality.
The outdoor patio makes Blaze Pizza a great place to grab brunch on a sunny day, after you’ve worked up an appetite walking one of the many Williamsburg’s walking trails.
Mellow Mushroom in Williamsburg
Address: 110 S Henry Street, Suite A, Williamsburg, VA, 23185
Mellow Mushroom serves up a unique atmosphere along with great pizza, and the Williamsburg location has a beautiful covered outdoor area where you can enjoy your pizza.
They offer gluten-free pizza options, salads, wings and signature cocktails. There are also vegan dining options available in both hoagies and pizza pies. For those who don’t restrict dairy, there’s a touch of uniqueness available in cheese selection.
For a spectacular meat-free dish, you should try the Holy Shiitake Pie. This pizza comes with an olive oil and garlic base and a variety of mushrooms: shitake, button and portobello. It also features caramelized onions, mozzarella and Wisoconson aged white cheddar. To top it off, there’s a garlic aioli swirl and a touch of black truffle oil.
Or, you can try something new with the Great White, which has sun-dried tomatoes, authentic feta cheese along with seasoned ricotta, provolone and mozzarella. If you prefer a red sauce, you can try the Kosmic Karma pie which also uses sheep’s milk feta cheese along with mozzarella featuring spinach, sun-dried roasted tomatoes and pesto.
Highway Pizza
Address: 3044 Richmond Rd Suite 101, Williamsburg, VA 23185
Highway Pizza is another great pizza joint option if you want a touch of unique atmosphere. License plates, road signs, car wheels, and other driving-themed decorations populate the walls and tables of the restaurant (the bathroom sink’s faucet is even a gas nozzle).
Highway Pizza has several events if you’re looking for some entertainment while you eat. Every Friday, they host karaoke, trivia is on Wednesdays, bike night is on Saturdays, and bingo on Sundays. The pizza restaurant also hosts comedy nights every now and then that are worth checking out.
These events make Highway Pizza a great place to mingle with locals, and as far as non-pizza goes, the restaurant’s Speed Bumps are a popular menu item. (Speed Bumps are rolled dough balls that look like tiny tires stuffed with your choice of meat and mozzarella cheese.)
When it comes to pizza, they offer classics like pepperoni pizza and margherita pizzas on hand-made crispy crusts (gluten-free pizzas are available for order). There are also unique and creative pizzas, such as the NachoMama pizza (which comes with nacho cheese, beef, tortilla chips, jalapeños, as well as red and green peppers – This is a must-try for any pizza or nacho lovers).
They’ve also got an extensive drink menu featuring signature cocktails and margaritas. Their bar is also stocked with wines and a large beer selection featuring national name brands as well as some from local Virginia breweries. If you’re looking for a night out on the town as a side order to your pizza, Highway is a good way to go.
Little Charlie’s Pizza
Address: 4511 John Tyler Hwy Unit C, Williamsburg, VA 23188
Little Charlie’s Pizza is a New York deli & pizza place. The owner, Charlie Messina, has been working in family-owned pizzerias since the 1970s when he was a young man in Brooklyn, New York.
The dining area is small, cozy, and simple, so some customers prefer pick up over dine in. However, the friendly staff create a warm atmosphere for all guests so you never feel unwelcome or rushed.
The dough and sauce is made fresh from scratch, promising high-quality pizza daily, and the menu features heroes, such as veal parmigiana and cheese steak, as well as a few pasta dishes.
The specialty pizzas stick to the classics like Hawaian, Meat Lovers and Margaritas. This is a great spot for anyone who wants a tried and true pizza pie for dinner. There’s New York style pizzas available, as well as Scicilians – what’s even better is you can buy both by the slice.
Choosing Your Williamsburg Pizza Place
Choosing the right pizzeria is never an easy task when you’re visiting a new town, especially when the city has as many great options as Williamsburg.
After you spend the day exploring the local history or splashing around in one of the waterparks, stop by any of these pizza restaurants for some of the best pizza in Williamsburg VA. It’s the perfect way to cap off a spectacular day.
If you’re all settled on what pizzeria you plan to visit during your trip but not sure what else you want to do, check out this list of attractions in the area – or our blog – for ideas. From delicious pizza to luxury spas, Williamsburg VA has it all. Start planning your trip now! You can also find tips & tricks for your travels at relaxandchill.us!